PCFormat Forum Archive

Hey

One of my co-workers is looking at buying an Apple computer. I am not well versed in Apple products, so I would appreciate your input.

Her requirements are:

• Be able to run Adobe CS5 comfortably.
• It must not die on large images, like, say, 100MB big or 12MP (4000px wide by 3000px high.)
• Create images for print.
• Handle the software needed to edit the images (ties in with point 1 but bears repeating.)
• Colour accuracy.
• Value for money.

Do you know if a glossy screen or matte screen would be better?
Any other ideas for other requirements that my colleague and I might be missing?

If the price is good enough, she will consider a Windows laptop.

Thanks

My input from a Windows perspective:

Any sufficient i5 with at least four logical cores AND an CUDA enabled gfx card (for CS5) should be fine for handling the applications, but screens, well, perhaps an external screen would be better.

Budget?

A PC equivalent will be much cheaper, that's for sure. MacBook Pro's in SA are extremely overpriced, especially the i5 and i7 variety, so unless she specifically wants a Mac it will be more cost effective going for a PC laptop. She would probably want at least a 15.4" but preferably a 17", unless she'll be using an external monitor...

The specs you say are right though yes, i5 or higher, preferably 6GB of RAM or higher, dedicated graphics with at least 256MB RAM, 7200 RPM drive or SSD. When it comes to screen it's down to personal preference, but glossy is generally better for graphic design and colour accuracy, provided the ambient lighting doesn't cause any glare. I never have issues with my MBP's glossy screen though.

Apples are synonymous with graphic design. So a decent MacBook Pro should handle Photoshop easily. However, what Ryan says is right: Apple laptops are expensive and you can get a better Win machine for the same price.

The Apple IPS screens will provide the best colour accuracy. A PC laptop would be cheaper.

Thanks guys. She doesn't have a definite budget right now, we're in the exploratory phase right now. I've told her to go to a local Incredible Connection and feel around on Photoshop on a Mac, and then ask/demand to do the same on a similarly priced Windows laptop. I've told her to try with both the trackpad and a mouse.

When buying a Mac, is CS5 normally bundled with?

Imho, Apple products are priced just right if you look at the components and *cough* compare apples with apples. The build quality is primarily what you pay for. I would go for the Mac. Macbook Pro's handle CS5 with a breeze. If you want to stay on the laptop side. And on a side note, the OS wont need to be re-installed every now and then...**Oh, and something you might not have known about Apple computers, they use secure memory allocation - so memory gets dynamically reserved for an application(not shared like on windows), and as soon as you exit the app, memory goes free. Making the overall experience fast and efficient.

**Apple magic mouse is awesome!
**incredible connection SUX!!! stay away - go to your nearest Apple store, and then test it. Only then go to normal IT store, same price, same specs, then test on that PC machine.

CS5 like any other software is not bundled. What you do get is the OS (32 & 64 bit already), and some built in apps, like Apple APP store, Safari, Mail, Quicktime, etc..

Any thing else?

I can echo what's been said about the Apple screens. My girlfriend's got a MBP and the screen on that thing is just incredible. It's certainly better than anything I've ever experienced, and I've had quite a few monitors.

I don't like Big Mac.

DAE_JA_VOO wrote:I can echo what's been said about the Apple screens. My girlfriend's got a MBP and the screen on that thing is just incredible. It's certainly better than anything I've ever experienced, and I've had quite a few monitors.

Yup, I love mine, and can't wait for my 27" Cinema Display!

For graphic design, Apple is definitely the way to go if you can afford the products. Another reason, besides those mentioned here already, is that most designers use Mac, and there are sometimes issues when opening a document or image that was saved on a Mac, on a PC. My girlfriend currently has that issue as she works on Mac at work and PC at home and sometimes has issues with Freehand and Adobe files, so she has to use my MBP at times, which is why I want to get an iMac or Mac Pro for home soon.

You will need a macbook with like min 4GB RAM.

I am running a macbook core2 duo with 2GB RAM and any file more than 20 MB starts slowing down photoshop... then again i have like 10 other apps running at the same time.

but i think min 4GB should be fine. if you can get an i7 or i5 that would be big bonus.

Windows would be much cheaper.

i personally feels macs are way overpriced compared to pcs. and that you pay for the name brand rather than anything else.


would rather get a great sony viavo or alienware.

Hmmm. Girlfriend had a high end Vaio and the build quality and screen of my MBP is way better. I wouldn't have bought my i7 MBP for what the iStore asks, but I got it for R7K less than retail so couldn't pass it up, and have never looked back. Really the best laptop I've ever used.